STBB #718 VOTE

[cascassette]

First of all, MzFk wins this one clearly for influence.. had scratches or bass or other input in like half the tracks!! Good work brother! Hope to work together again in a future BB.

1. STBB#718 Calc X MzFk [ Till the End of the Week ]
2. STBB [ DWBH ] SoDamnFresh X JoaGymshoe w/ MzFk & Nindyo
3. ƧƬദദ#718 [Alinea x FE_Joose x Balstyrico]

For SoDamnFresh X JoaGymshoe w/ MzFk & Nindyo.. where's the midi part(s)?

[Granny David]

STBB #718 RESULT

Winner/s
Please read thread below




There were multiple DQ's this week due to the (specia)l rules:

- Only collabs are valid entries, all team members need to vote
- Must use 'Midi'

[JoaGymshoe]

For SoDamnFresh X JoaGymshoe w/ MzFk & Nindyo.. where's the midi part(s)?

man, talked with SDF about a bassline in the early stages just coz I thought it would be cool to have a funky bass.
got the one stem track and never thought again if it had the required 'sprinkles'.
was focussed with making the vocal parts and getting everybody's stuff on/in.

as far as other rules..
I thought the track was supposed to be happy and dancy. I suppose that's sorta subjective...

check the vibe voted for both team Balstyrico and my team's beats..

and then the rule where it says, all participants need to vote in order to win..

all in all kinda messy.

aight..
on this week's winners..
since both popular vote Balsty, Alinea and FE_Joose and my team SDF, MzFk and Nindyo didn't comply with the rules..
( at least I think so..I'll check with SDF )
and also Larry Bird didn't vote on the Goodwill collab.
Alinea and MzFk didn't use midi either I just received word
edited Granny's post above
i feel it is the right result coz it adhers to the dancy and happy vibe aswell..
guys plz tell me you used some 'midi' on top of this?

so I've had some thoughts for next year..
to possibly not have the: everybody has to vote rule.
and maybe 1 collab per person.. thinking what the consequences of that would be?.. people would look for other people quicker..
as opposed to all collabing with MzFk..jokes
possibly some help from moderators in 'matchmaking' ?
a fixed ruleset which lends itself to collabing.
okay.. just thoughts.. input is welcome.

yes, agreed check the vibe.. pity we didn't have more contenders..
what a messy week..
on to the next one!

pz and love all!

[MOXATRON]

Yo! sorry missed the voting this week. My bad.

Yeah this week was a bit messy.
It would be good to try and arrange the collab situation some how?

Hard as you need even amount's of people that are entering, and how would you match people up?

Names in a hat? or something more logical?


Peace. Mox.

[JoaGymshoe]

shit just got crazier again..
MzfK wrote he only used drums and percussion on the track with Alinea

[MzFk]

Damn what a mess is this? time to chill brothers and sisters. I m a man of peace, I m just here for the love of music. I feel sorry for that situations. I agree with Joa should have been just one collab per person. I think Joa and SDF have won, Votes are votes. Let s not make this week looks like Trump on elections results please.
Ain t got nothing but love for you all.
Peace

[FE_Joose]

1:Checkthevibe X Dsensei
2:SoDamnFresh X JoaGymshoe w/ MzFk & Nindyo
3:Calc X Mzfk till the End of the Week

this was fun beat family!! much love. this collab got me writing again lol so thank you!

[JoaGymshoe]

aight.. here's the solution..
Balstyrico, Alinea and FE_Joose win coz they got the popular vote.
we'll waive the: voting by all rule.. (prob for good )
if it turns out SDF did use midi he, Mzfk, Nindyo and I get a joined win..but I don't think that's the case.

some might feel and say the win is not important to them.. others proudly put it on their sc page
so I do take this seriously.

please all speak your minds.

Congrats Balstyrico, Alinea and FE_Joose!



edit: hehe, it's okay MzFk.. just a mess is all

and FE_Joose.. thanks for your late vote

pz Joa

[FE_Joose]

oh damn ive had a long day at work... my apologies collab partners!!!

[MzFk]

Ahhh that s better, Now we can all have a good week end. Congrates to Balstyrico, Alinea and FE_Joose.
Take good care eveybody of you and others.

[waxramble]

I think in the monthly battles before, we at one point had a rule stating one vote per 'team' or collaboration basically. I do think the rule requiring vote to count on 'solo' battles does encourage people to check back in and participate - so I think that should still stand in my opinion. I think this gets more messy when everyone is a collab though, so on future collab battles a rule saying at least one person from the group must vote will make that a bit more simple.

It sounds like a conclusion was reached for this battle, so we don't need any recounts or lawsuits here

Thanks Joa for helping settle this and congrats to Alinea, FE_Joose, and Balstyrico

[JoaGymshoe]

I think in the monthly battles before, we at one point had a rule stating one vote per 'team' or collaboration basically. I do think the rule requiring vote to count on 'solo' battles does encourage people to check back in and participate - so I think that should still stand in my opinion. I think this gets more messy when everyone is a collab though, so on future collab battles a rule saying at least one person from the group must vote will make that a bit more simple.

It sounds like a conclusion was reached for this battle, so we don't need any recounts or lawsuits here

Thanks Joa for helping settle this and congrats to Alinea, FE_Joose, and Balstyrico

yup, the ' must vote to win' was an improvement on the regular weeklies, def keepin' that.
clearly interpretale rules are handy too.. but there will likely always be a subjective side to musical stuff.
yeah, seems like a good plan to implement that..I'll do it in the Traditions thread in a few.

cheers!

[LarryByrd]

My bad yall, I thought the whole thing was pushed back an extra day

[Lalaina]

Yo thanks you all for the wonderful feels; and thanks guys for clearing the mess; and shout out for my teammate Basltyrico for that soulful beat and FE_Joose for kicking it right, also many thanks to my man Mzfk for introducing me to this wonderful community !

No worry about the late vote FEJoose, for me just playing is already winning ! Really look forward to do collab again, I know that"s life but too bad so many didn't make it this week, but that wil happen another time !

To make collaboration time easier, maybe set a rule asking to share a central element of the beat; for example, you must use another person's drum track and use it as it is for at least X number of bars (so it's not too much of a constraint and you can make a switch, a break or whatever ) So that way it can be more appealing at first . Just a tought.

And thanks Joa for pushing us to do collabz all the past weeks !

Peace

[JoaGymshoe]

My bad yall, I thought the whole thing was pushed back an extra day

ah, yes, understandable..
no worries.. it was a messy affair overall

Yo thanks you all for the wonderful feels; and thanks guys for clearing the mess; and shout out for my teammate Basltyrico for that soulful beat and FE_Joose for kicking it right, also many thanks to my man Mzfk for introducing me to this wonderful community !

No worry about the late vote FEJoose, for me just playing is already winning ! Really look forward to do collab again, I know that"s life but too bad so many didn't make it this week, but that wil happen another time !

To make collaboration time easier, maybe set a rule asking to share a central element of the beat; for example, you must use another person's drum track and use it as it is for at least X number of bars (so it's not too much of a constraint and you can make a switch, a break or whatever ) So that way it can be more appealing at first . Just a tought.

And thanks Joa for pushing us to do collabz all the past weeks !

Peace

yes, collabs rock bro!..

taking all you guys' ideas into consideration and will apply some for coming years